A Crooked World

“The Unspeakable and the Uneatable I and II,” “Schools of Magic,”
“A Crooked World,” “Blood of the Changeling,” “The Beginning”
Excalibur #7-12
Written by Tini Howard
Art by Marcus To (8-12) and Ed Santos (7, 8)
Color art by Erick Arciniega

The break in publishing as a result of the pandemic was rough on all of the series in the Dawn of X line, but I think it had the worst impact on Excalibur as it was entering a run of issues introducing Saturnyne and Otherworld that demanded a more immediate memory of a fairly tangled narrative web involving multiple realities. I think Howard’s story is relatively straightforward in its plot beats, but the plain aesthetics of Marcus To and Erick Arciniega’s art get in her way by doing pretty much nothing at all to give the reader visual cues that we are looking at different realities, which makes the story more difficult to follow as a casual reader than it ought to be. Arciniega could have done a lot to get this across, but no – the colors are basic and utterly devoid of vibes. To’s art is fine with fundamentals and quite good when it comes to rendering faces, but he seems entirely incapable of drawing compelling backgrounds or conveying atmosphere, which is a big problem on a fantasy series. He’d be fine on most mainline Marvel books or even on another current X-Men series like New Mutants or X-Factor, but he continues to hobble Howard’s ambitious ideas. 

The good news is that in Excalibur #12 Howard pays off on the majority of the narrative threads she’d been seeding through the first 11 issues of the series. The issue centers on Apocalypse as he and Rictor enact a ritual creating a gateway to the long-lost Arrako, with Gambit unknowingly completing the spell by dispatching the disembodied form of his old enemy Candra. The plot is satisfying enough, particularly as lead-in to X of Swords, but the best thing here is Howard’s thoughtful characterization of Apocalypse. 

Her Apocalypse is blithe in his monomaniacal pursuit of reaching Arrako, expertly exploiting everyone – his old friends the Externals, his new coven in Excalibur, Saturnyne of Otherworld – to get what he needs. The reader is encouraged to side with Apocalypse in terms of his goals but to also reckon with the degree to which he is a sociopath. In this issue we see exactly what becomes of people when they stop being of use to him, and it opens up the question of what will happen when Excalibur – or the Quiet Council of Krakoa – is no longer of value to his quest. She and Hickman are very much on the same page with Apocalypse, and I think it’s clear that this nuanced redefinition of the character will end up being part of the legacy of this run of comics that makes it into Marvel’s movie universe down the line.